Arise Saga

How the score works

Every signal, its weight, and the reason it carries that weight. If you disagree with a number here, you are disagreeing with something specific.

The arithmetic

Each signal has a weight and a result: pass counts the full weight, partial counts half, fail counts nothing. A signal that does not apply to the page - alt text on a page with no images - is left out of both sides, so it neither rewards nor punishes. The score is the weighted points earned divided by the weighted points available, out of 100. A is 90 or above, B is 75, C is 60, D is 40.

Technical SEO health is scored separately and shown beside the AI score. Folding it in would let a fast, tidy, well-linked page hide the fact that AI crawlers cannot read it - which is the one measurement classic SEO tools do not make.

Where the weights come from

Three signals carry weight because they have a measured effect size: cited sources, statistics and quotations each moved AI citation visibility by 30-40% in GEO: Generative Engine Optimization (Aggarwal et al., KDD 2024, arXiv:2311.09735), which tested nine tactics across 10,000 queries. Keyword stuffing did nothing in that study, which is why there is no keyword-density check here.

Everything else is a reasoned judgement, weighted lower to say so. The three heaviest - render dependency, crawler access in robots.txt, and crawler access at the server - are the same class of failure: the crawler arrives and leaves with nothing, and no other signal can compensate.

The 30 signals

SignalWeightWhy
JavaScript-rendered content13 / 203If the content only exists after JavaScript runs, most AI crawlers never see it. Every other signal is moot.
AI crawler access13 / 203robots.txt rules for GPTBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot, Google-Extended and CCBot. Blocked is blocked.
Structured data13 / 203Schema.org JSON-LD tells a machine what a page is instead of making it guess. Guessing is where citations go wrong.
AI crawlers actually served12 / 203robots.txt is a request; the server has the last word. We fetch the page as each crawler and compare with a browser. A CDN can 403 a bot that robots.txt allows.
FAQ / Q&A format10 / 203Question-and-answer blocks with FAQPage schema are the passages most often lifted whole into an answer.
Entity clarity9 / 203A model that cannot tell what your page is about has no reason to cite it.
Answerability9 / 203Short, self-contained paragraphs and lists can be quoted; a wall of prose cannot.
Cited sources9 / 203Linking claims to their sources moved AI citation rates 30-40% in the KDD 2024 GEO study (Aggarwal et al.). One of three tactics with a measured effect.
Concrete statistics8 / 203Concrete figures, dates and percentages. Also 30-40% in the GEO study. Adjectives are not evidence.
Direct answer up front8 / 203Does the opening actually address the headline? Engines lift the first paragraph far more often than the middle.
Page title7 / 203The most-quoted string on the page. Short, specific, present.
Meta description7 / 203What search and preview surfaces show. Present, and inside the length that gets truncated.
Author / E-E-A-T7 / 203A named person with a real page behind them. AI engines weight identifiable expertise.
Content depth7 / 203Thin pages are not cited. This is a floor, not a target.
Quotations7 / 203Quoted material with attribution. The third of the three GEO-study tactics.
Freshness6 / 203A real, recent date. Stale content is discounted.
Question-shaped headings6 / 203A heading phrased as the question people type is the passage most likely to match a query.
Passage chunkability6 / 203Retrieval works on passages, not pages. Sections of roughly 40-600 words survive being cut out; a 2,000-word block gets truncated and a 15-word one carries no context.
H1 heading5 / 203One clear H1. Two is ambiguity; none is a page with no subject.
Heading structure5 / 203H2 and H3 sections are how a long page gets split for retrieval.
Tables and lists5 / 203Structured blocks are lifted whole into answers far more readily than prose.
llms.txt4 / 203Scored on shape, not presence: H1, blockquote summary, H2 sections of markdown links with descriptions. An empty file is not a summary.
Internal links4 / 203How a crawler maps the rest of your site from this page.
Semantic HTML4 / 203main, article, nav, section: the tags that tell a parser which part is the content.
Sentence fluency4 / 203Long sentences are hard to lift cleanly. Fluency raised citation rates in the GEO study.
Content vs boilerplate4 / 203How much of the page is actually this page, versus nav and footer repeated sitewide.
Open Graph3 / 203What Teams, Slack, WhatsApp and X show when the link is shared.
Image alt text3 / 203Alt text on images that carry meaning. Decorative images marked alt="" are correct and excluded.
Definition sentence3 / 203One plain "X is a ..." sentence near the top is the exact shape a definitional query retrieves.
Canonical URL2 / 203One URL per page, declared. Duplicates split whatever credit the page earns.

What this cannot see

Whether an AI actually cites you. That depends on what the rest of the internet says about your site - links, mentions, reputation - which a page audit cannot measure. This tool checks the half you control: whether the page can be read, understood and quoted. The other half is earned, not configured.

These weights are a judgement and arguments against them are welcome. Send them to the contact page with the signal named.